Sometimes the past is one of the best learning tools around! Use the following Real-Life Errors & Omissions Claim Situation involving an agent taking on what should have been the buyers’ due diligence to avoid a similar legal showdown happening to you in your everyday real estate career. And be sure to have a good Real Estate E&O Insurance policy in place to protect you in case you find yourself in the middle of a court battle over negligence.

A Real Estate agent was working with prospective buyers who were searching for a residential property for their growing family. The agent showed them several properties before they decided to submit an offer on a home that recently underwent a complete renovation, including a two-room addition.

Problem:
The renovation was completed by an unlicensed contractor who failed to obtain the necessary building permits. Moreover, the property was located in a state that did not require the owners to complete a seller’s property disclosure statement, leaving the buyers to determine whether any defective conditions existed through the engagement of experts.

Mistake:
Since the buyers were busy with their careers and the school activities of their children, the agent volunteered to do the due diligence for the buyers. This included hiring a home inspector and termite inspector. In accepting the agent’s offer, the buyers assumed that he would also research whether or not the project was “legal.”

Result:
Approximately five months after moving into the property, the buyers received a letter from the city informing them that the renovations were completed without the required permits. The ensuing building inspection discovered that the addition did not conform to the building codes since it lacked a load-bearing wall. The buyers then sued the sellers,
the listing agent, the home inspector, and their buyers’ agent for failing to either disclose or detect the property’s nonconformance. The parties ultimately resolved the litigation after the defendants agreed to pay for the remediation and obtain the certificate of occupancy.

Prevention:
An agent should never volunteer to take on the due diligence for buyers by ordering or attending inspections on their behalf. If there’s any defective condition with the property, the agent will likely be sued for negligently referring the inspectors while putting themselves in the position where a jury could determine that they fraudulently induced the buyers into the purchase. Sound risk management on the part of an agent is to have the buyers select the inspectors and not become actively involved in the conversation between the buyers and the inspector. Although it is best to be present during the inspection should the client seek assistance, an agent should not be interpreting an inspector’s findings or recommendations. The agent may later be held accountable for failing to address something pointed out by the inspector. Lastly, always recommend that the buyers contact the controlling authority for conformance inquiries.

Do you have a similar story involving negligence, failure to disclose, or nonconforming renovations to share with us? Send us your learning experience or just let us know what you think about this one! Just leave a reply below!

If you have any questions about Pearl’s Errors & Omissions Insurance for real estate professionals, give us a call at 800.447.4982—whether you’re looking for a new E&O policy or have questions about your current one. We’d love to hear from you!

You can also visit our website for E&O insurance just for real estate professionals, www.pearlinsurance.com/eo, to find out more about our quality Errors & Omissions program, including policy features, risk management tools, and much more. Or get a quick estimate now!

Recently, we came across a couple of articles asking to what extent a real estate professional holds the burden of assisting clients rather than taking advantage of a good real estate deal themselves. On the one hand, a REALTOR owes it to their buyer clients to show them any properties they may be interested in, and to their seller clients to find the best financial offer out there. On the other hand, the agent may also be a buyer, and their offer may be the best one the seller receives.

Real estate agents, and REALTORS in particular, are held to the standards of the National Association of REALTORS (NAR), including its Code of Ethics. This includes protecting and promoting the interests of their clients, and treating all parties honestly. So if you know you want to purchase a property as a rental investment, but your client expresses an interest in it, what do you do? Bite your tongue and show them the property without telling them you would like to purchase it? If you are representing the seller, whatever offer entails the highest price would be in their best interest, right?

These questions can be tricky, as can the other point the writer brings up about how REALTORS should want more first-time homebuyers to have a chance to purchase rather than getting beat out by more knowledgeable real estate professionals. Should agents have to endure a waiting period wherein the listing is exposed to the market for a certain amount of time, before they are allowed to purchase a property someone already has their eye on and is willing to put in an offer for?

Here is the Part 1 article from writer Tom Kelly for Inman News.

In response to the comments Kelly received on his first article, “Should Real Estate Agents Get First Dibs on New Listings?”, his Part 2 article discusses the audience response, and follows it up with a Washington state case that delves into this very topic.

“The responses fell into two main pots,” writes Kelly. “Readers said agents should be allowed to buy if it was in the best interest of the seller. Others who responded thought that agents should be allowed to purchase a property as soon as it is listed, provided they knowingly had no other active clients who wanted the same home.”

It sounds like it all comes down to the “treating all parties honestly” part of the code. In the case of the agent who bought from under his client’s nose, he not only bought a property he knew his client was interested in, but he also relayed some personal, and possibly incorrect information to the listing agent to keep his client from winning the bid. To make things worse, the agent bought the property under his wife’s name, presumably to hide his indiscretion.

Court documents show that the seller’s agent didn’t know the buyer’s agent’s wife was related to the buyer’s agent, or he wouldn’t have participated in the deal. Besides this lapse of honesty, there were two other areas it seems the buyer’s agent went beyond ethical judgement as well as Washington law by attempting to beat the system: 1) He seemingly ignored Washington state real estate law requiring a buyer’s agent to “be loyal to the buyer by taking no action that is adverse or detrimental to the buyer’s interest in a transaction (and) to timely disclose to the buyer any conflicts of interest.” 2) The law also rules against revealing confidential information after the agent-client relations ceases or has been finalized.

Although the settlement itself is confidential, it is obvious the agent was a bit underhanded in his dealings with his buyer client as well as the seller. Hopefully he had a good E&O policy in place to help him with the legal costs, but it is likely his name has been dragged through the mud in the real estate community.

What do you think—should agents be made to wait until a property has been listed for a while before they get a chance to purchase it, allowing less knowledgeable buyers some time to work out the kinks in their offer? Is it punishing those in the real estate profession to do so?

Guy Chipman from the Texas Association of REALTORS^® wrote a well-received article entitled “Errors, Omissions, and Lawsuits, Oh My!” on the key lessons he learned while looking for an E&O provider. We will be posting one tip per week from Chipman’s article, with Pearl’s comments in italics. See what Pearl E&O coverage offers.

2. Make sure all your services are covered. If the insurer can’t cover all of the services your company offers—residential, commercial, property management—it’s probably not the right company to meet your E&O needs.

Pearl’s policy covers property managers, appraisers, auctioneers, assistants to agents and business brokers. Beyond covering all aspects of real estate practice, we offers flexibility to ensure that each individual realtor’s individual needs are met. Pearl offers per claim coverage and aggregate limits ranging from $250,000 to $5,000,000, and deductibles from $1,000 to $25,000, or higher. Pearl gives all of our customers’ individualized attention in order to customize a plan that is ideal for their needs and business focus.

Have you ever struggled with an E&O agent unable to meet your needs? How do you pick the right E&O Provider? Let us know by posting a comment below!

Guy Chipman from the Texas Association of REALTORS^® wrote a well-received article entitled “Errors, Omissions, and Lawsuits, Oh My!” on the key lessons he learned while looking for an E&O provider. We will be posting one tip per week from Chipman’s article, with Pearl’s comments in italics. See what Pearl E&O coverage offers.

1. Find a specialized agent. Not every insurance office has an agent who is knowledgeable about this type of insurance. It’s a specialized field, and an agent will need expertise in both real estate and malpractice insurance to quote this coverage effectively.

Pearl agrees that without experience and expertise in Real Estate E&O coverage, an insurer doesn’t have much to offer to a real estate professional. At Pearl, we’ve offered Real Estate E&O for over 30 years, and recently completely reinvigorated our coverage to make it best in class among E&O providers. We added new features like a mold endorsement with higher limits, deductible reduction for early claim resolution, a higher limit open house property damage coverage option, and improved many prior features of our plan.

Have you ever struggled with an E&O agent unable to meet your needs? How do you pick the right E&O Provider? Let us know by posting a comment below!

Sometimes the past is one of the best learning tools around! Use the following Real-Life Errors & Omissions Claim Situation involving a delayed response to a real estate errors and omissions lawsuit to avoid a similar legal showdown happening to you in your everyday real estate career. And be sure to have a good Real Estate E&O Insurance policy in place to protect you in case you find yourself in the middle of a court battle over negligence.

Following the close of escrow on a residential property, a Real Estate broker and his agent were sued by the buyers for allegedly failing to provide the required Seller’s Property Disclosure Statement. The broker and his agent were adamant that they were in compliance and would have been able to demonstrate from documentary evidence that it was provided to the buyers’ agent. The evidence included a facsimile transmission of a cover letter addressing the “attached” property disclosure, along with electronic mail exchanges with the buyers’ agent discussing the property’s condition.

Problem:
Believing that the lawsuit was frivolous, the broker and agent simply ignored it. They also ignored the ensuing Motion for Default brought by the buyers’ attorney for failing to file an answer to the complaint.

Mistake:
By ignoring both the lawsuit and default motion, the court entered a five-figure judgment against the Real Estate brokerage. And to make matters worse, the Default Judgment was not tendered to the Real Estate Errors & Omissions insurance carrier until one month later.

Result:
Despite an all-out effort on the part of the defense attorney assigned by the Errors & Omissions insurance carrier, the Default Judgment could not be overturned due to the delayed responses on the part of the brokerage. Furthermore, the insurance carrier was under no obligation to pay the judgment since the Real Estate brokerage failed to comply with the terms and conditions of its Errors & Omissions policy by not providing timely notice of the claim.

Prevention:
Many jurisdictions have very strict deadlines for filing court documents. In this case it’s quite clear that the Real Estate brokerage could have avoided its problems if the lawsuit was reported immediately to the Errors & Omissions insurance carrier. And given the favorable evidence in the transaction file, the claim may have been voluntarily dismissed once the buyers’ attorney was presented the irrefutable evidence. In order to preserve this evidence, it is very important not to destroy your file following a closing so that an effective defense can be asserted on your behalf. The transaction file should include the following:

• the date and time of all meetings or phone conversations and a list of all participants

• e-mails and faxes

• verification that what you say and write is correct—keep a record of all verified information, contracts, agency disclosures, seller disclosures, and closing documents with the appropriate signatures. And never sign anything for your client.

Do you have a similar story involving negligence to share with us? Send us your learning experience or just let us know what you think about this one! Just leave a reply below!

If you have any questions about Pearl’s Errors & Omissions Insurance for real estate professionals, give us a call at 800.447.4982—whether you’re looking for a new E&O policy or have questions about your current one. We’d love to hear from you!

You can also visit our website for E&O insurance just for real estate professionals, www.pearlinsurance.com/eo, to find out more about our quality Errors & Omissions program, including policy features, risk management tools, and much more.

You’re working harder than ever—shouldn’t your E&O provider do the same?

Pearl Insurance knows you’ve put in the extra effort to remain viable in this industry, and so have we. For the last three decades, we’ve continually innovated Pearl’s E&O coverage to keep up with the ever-changing demands of the real estate market. And we’ve once again made it new and improved!

We’re so excited to announce major enhancements to our Real Estate Errors & Omissions policy, which Pearl insureds will enjoy right away:

• Environmental Failure to Advise up to full policy limits
• Public Relations Advisory Services
• Lockbox coverage to full policy limits
• Consent to Settle
• Mold Endorsement with increased limits—NEW!
• Subpoena Assistance—NEW!
• Free 3-year Extended Reporting Period—NEW!
• Loss Mitigation Credit—NEW!
• Network and Privacy coverage with a $25,000 sublimit—NEW!
• Deductible Reduction for Early Claims Resolution—IMPROVED! Applies to both defense and damages!
• Open House Property Damage coverage—IMPROVED! Up to FULL policy limits!
• Agent-Owned Property Coverage—IMPROVED! No waiting period applies!
• And many more benefits and NEW improvements!

Pearl E&O Insurance: It’s already robust!

The key to developing a good relationship in any business is to listen to what your customer says and pay attention to their needs. Not to mention, imagine the number of Real Estate E&O claims that in the long run had something to do with poor communication! In the March/April 2011 issue of Selling Power, John H. Melchinger offers 9 tips to become a better listener. Here is an excerpt:

1. Put aside all personal issues. Be attentive and concentrate on hearing what the speaker has to say.
2. Comment on what you hear, and individualize your comments: “Cheryl, that’s obviously very important to you.” If you train yourself to comment meaningfully, the speaker will know you are listening and may offer further information.
3. Show empathy. If you respond to human issues, people will respond to you.
4. Don’t ignore opportunities for humor. When it arises naturally our of a conversation, humor enhances what may otherwise be an overly somber situation. Avoid sarcasm, however, which is rarely humorous.
5. Be aware of nonverbal communication: silence, facial expressions, tone of voice, body gestures. These can be telling symptoms, but don’t allow these messages to be the basis for speedy conclusions.
6. Know the value of silence. A brief period of silence will generally cause the speaker to produce more in-depth responses and allow both of you to reflect on what’s been said, ask additional questions, seek further clarification, or provide more information.
7. Ask questions to clarify information. The best indicators that you hear and understand are your questions and how you ask them.
8. Be sure you are not making inaccurate assumptions. When the speaker leaves a point unfinished, finish it yourself and ask for agreement, or simply ask the speaker to finish it.
9. Be careful. Most people have an almost immediate grasp of the obvious, but few of us can grasp immediately what a speaker means to convey.

Sometimes the past is one of the best learning tools around! Use the following Real-Life Errors & Omissions Claim Situation involving a REALTOR^® calendar error to avoid a similar legal showdown happening to you in your everyday real estate career. And be sure to have a good Real Estate E&O Insurance policy in place to protect you in case you find yourself in the middle of a court battle over negligence.

A Real Estate professional was serving as the commercial leasing broker for a shopping plaza on behalf of the holder of a 15-year ground lease that included an option to renew for four successive five-year terms. The renewal was contingent upon the ground leaseholder giving written notice to the plaza owner nine months prior to the expiration of the lease. As part of his duties, the broker agreed to accept the responsibility of exercising the renewal option as well as those of the six retail tenants in the plaza.

Problem:
The ground lease and the retail leases were not timely renewed.

Mistake:
The leasing broker marked the wrong date in his calendar, therefore missing the deadline.

Result:
Although the first extension did not occur within the time frame allowed by the ground lease, the plaza owner, who discovered the oversight, still accepted the renewal. However, the retail tenants refused to renew their respective leases under the same terms despite the broker’s frantic efforts to salvage the deals. Five of the tenants notified the broker and leaseholder that they would be relocating, leaving much of the property vacant at the conclusion of the lease period. The broker attempted but failed to locate suitable tenants for the plaza, resulting in a significant shortfall in revenue for the leaseholder. A lawsuit was then filed against the broker alleging negligence and sought reimbursement for lost rental income. After several rounds of negotiations, the parties settled the litigation well into six figures.

Prevention:
If the broker took a moment to carefully review the lease agreements and establish an effective calendar diary system, the error could have been avoided. A sound diary system includes the creation of a backup measure in the event the first notification method fails. Furthermore, it’s always a good practice to conduct periodic reviews of your contractual obligations to ensure that they’re well understood and in compliance. Many lawsuits arise over simple clerical errors that cost the real estate community thousands of dollars in legal fees and settlements. It also results in spending time and effort to fend off regulatory complaints brought by unsatisfied clients, not to mention the possibility of license suspension or revocation.

Do you have a similar story involving negligence to share with us? Send us your learning experience or just let us know what you think about this one! Just leave a reply below!

If you have any questions about Pearl’s Errors & Omissions Insurance for real estate professionals, give us a call at 800.447.4982—whether you’re looking for a new E&O policy or have questions about your current one. We’d love to hear from you!

You can also visit our website for E&O insurance just for real estate professionals, www.pearlinsurance.com/eo, to find out more about our quality Errors & Omissions program, including policy features, risk management tools, and much more.